https://www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/watchmen/s01
=======================
المراجعات بالغالب قاعدة تمدح فيه، وصحيح ما عندي ثقة بLindelof بس يبدو بيطلع شئ مقبول هذه المرة. المسلسل راح يبث على hbo ب20 أكتوبر هذا الشهر.
هذا لو ضبط مع the boys فبتكون سنة مسلسلات سوبر هيروز كبيرة!
indieWireThe series' scope is astonishing given its subject matter, and even more so given its relentless entertainment value.
CBRLindelof's Watchmen is bold, creative and challenging, maintaining a faithfulness to the source material, or its spirit, at least, without being overly reverential... It's fully realized, engaging and, yes, weird, but in all of the right ways (squidfall!)
USA TodaySo much energy as is spent on the sociopolitical elements of the series, but "Watchmen" is at its best when it tries a little less hard to be profound and instead focuses on the fascinating and deep cast of characters.
SlashfilmLindelof and his team have done the impossible - they've captured the superhero deconstruction elements that stood out in Moore and Gibbons' work while also expanding on their world-building.
io9.comNicole Kassell does a wondrous job of immediately pulling you into this story and bowling you over with imagery that's both beautiful and utterly devastating... But there are so many moments when Watchmen's debut episode falls short of saying anything.
VarietyLindelof keeps scribbling in the margins, adding in more and more story that may yet pay off but that takes perhaps undue patience in the interim.
=======================
المراجعات بالغالب قاعدة تمدح فيه، وصحيح ما عندي ثقة بLindelof بس يبدو بيطلع شئ مقبول هذه المرة. المسلسل راح يبث على hbo ب20 أكتوبر هذا الشهر.
هذا لو ضبط مع the boys فبتكون سنة مسلسلات سوبر هيروز كبيرة!